Dental extractions have long been a point of contention in the field of orthodontics. Traditionally viewed as a necessary step to achieve ideal facial and dental aesthetics in certain cases, the practice has faced criticism and scepticism, particularly from some clinicians and braces manufacturers. These entities often claim that they can treat every case without resorting to dental extractions and suggest that extractions could harm breathing and facial profile. However, a closer examination of the latest literature and scientific evidence reveals a different story.
The Role of Extractions in Orthodontics
Orthodontic treatment aims to improve dental aesthetics, function, and overall oral health. In some cases, dental extractions are essential to achieve these goals, especially when dealing with overcrowding or severe malocclusion or facilitating better alignment of the teeth and jaws. Extractions can create the necessary space to correct these issues, leading to improved dental alignment and facial aesthetics.
Debunking Myths: TMJ, Breathing, and Facial Profile Concerns
Concerns have been raised about the potential negative effects of dental extractions on the temporomandibular joint (TMJ), breathing, and facial profile. However, recent literature provides substantial evidence to the contrary.
A systematic review published in the Journal of Orthodontics found no significant long-term impact of orthodontic extractions on TMJ health. The study concluded that when extractions are performed as part of a well-planned orthodontic treatment, they do not increase the risk of TMJ disorders.
Similarly, fears that extractions adversely affect breathing have been largely unfounded. Research in the American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics demonstrated that extractions do not lead to compromised airway space or negatively impact respiratory function. These findings are crucial in dispelling myths about the dangers of extractions to breathing.
The concern that extractions might negatively alter a patient’s facial profile is also a significant consideration for both practitioners and patients. However, contemporary research indicates that, when extractions are appropriately indicated and executed with suitable biomechanical strategies, the resultant facial aesthetics can meet or exceed expectations. A balanced and harmonious facial profile can be maintained or achieved, contradicting the claims that extractions invariably lead to less aesthetically pleasing outcomes.
Unfounded Claims and the Importance of Professional Judgment
Claims by some clinicians and braces manufacturers about the universality of non-extraction treatments and the alleged harms of extraction procedures are not substantiated by the current body of scientific literature. Such assertions overlook the complexity of orthodontic diagnoses and the individualized nature of treatment planning. Orthodontic treatment, including the decision to extract, should always be predicated on a thorough diagnosis and a tailored treatment plan that considers the unique needs and conditions of each patient.
The orthodontic community agrees that no single treatment modality can address every clinical situation. The decision to proceed with dental extractions is made after a comprehensive evaluation of the patient’s specific dental and facial characteristics. This includes the use of advanced diagnostic tools and techniques to ensure that the proposed treatment aligns with the goals of achieving optimal functional and aesthetic outcomes.
Conclusion
The decision to incorporate dental extractions into orthodontic treatment is a nuanced one, guided by the principles of achieving the best possible outcome for the patient. Far from the detrimental effects suggested by some, the latest literature supports the practice of extractions when indicated, showing that it does not negatively impact TMJ health, breathing, or facial aesthetics. As with all medical treatments, the key lies in individualized patient care, informed by the latest research and carried out with expert clinical judgment. Orthodontists continue to rely on a foundation of scientific evidence to guide their practices, ensuring that patients receive the most effective, safe, and appropriate treatment for their specific needs.
Back to Blog
I recommend and prescribe orthodontic treatments to my patients as if they were my own family and I value meaningful relationships based on communication, confidence and trust.
“I'm very happy with my treatment and results. I was delighted with Dr. Erfan Salloum's attention to detail, and so happy he took the time...”
“Over the moon with the results from my orthodontic treatment at Dublin Orthodontics. I can not speak more highly of Dr. Erfan Salloum and his...”
